10 Things I Hate About You
Again, this is a show I shouldn’t like. A high-school show based on a movie that was released ten years ago (how often are those shows any good?). But this isn’t a typical CW-type teen show with bad acting, ridiculous situations, and insane sexual situations. This is a modern show with an old-school heart.
Teen sisters Kat & Bianca move to a new city with their widower father and try to fit into their new school. Bianca dreams of being in the popular crowd—by way of the cheerleading squad—but always manages to inadvertently insult the team captain, who makes her do humiliating things as penance. Kat wants nothing to do with petty high school desires; she’s out to save the world.
The show is very clever, and even the “seen it before” plots are given facelifts by the tight lines and the actors’ abilities to raise their game. Meaghan Jette Martin plays Bianca perfectly. She can have a bit of “over-her-head” moments and yet remain strong in our minds. She usually plays the “straight girl”, and has the ability to make us like her while pining for one boy—and rebuffing another who pines for her. That’s tough to manage; to be lovesick in one scene and confidently managing to not break someone else’s heart in another. Larry Miller plays the father, Walter, and I can’t think of another actor who could fill the role as perfectly as he does. He got thrown in the deep end of the pool with the death of his wife (which does not define the character as it normally would on a TV show; it happened, and he misses her—but he has two teenage daughters to raise), but he deals with it as most real fathers would.
The supporting actors also play their characters well. Unfortunately, the characters didn’t get the chance to progress beyond the surface stereotypes (headstrong/bitch cheerleader captain, befuddled/lovesick boy pining for someone out of his league, good-looking idiot football captain, goofy). Of note is Ethan Peck’s Patrick, the “loner”, brooding love interest of Kat. He, too, hasn’t had much to do to make his character more than the “rebel without a cause”, but he holds himself incredibly well in scenes with Lindsey Shaw’s Kat—and was been given some more to do in the back half of the season (which, sadly, lacked the magic of the first half).
And that brings us to Lindsey Shaw, who gained my attention in a big way in the fantastic Aliens in America a few years back. In that show, she was a supporting character, but on this one, she’s the center of attention. Bianca and Kat both have their plotlines, but the show focuses on Kat’s life more. And it’s well-deserved because Shaw is fantastic. She has an incredibly magnetic presence on screen—even when the scripts let her down a little. I don’t want to jinx her career or anything, but I could see big things from her. Maybe not on the big screen (yet), but she could be a major force on TV for years to come if she keeps finding great shows to be on. Unfortunately, this show, like Aliens in America, didn’t get a second season, so she’ll have to try to find another one to shine in.